|
Post by Erniewan on May 8, 2012 17:00:11 GMT -6
Maybe if his gameplay style wasn't so scummy, people wouldn't try to lynch him for it? I don't see mafia wanting him out of the way this early in the game, but I could see them bandwagoning him for a (mis)lynch. However, the people on his wagon were myself, Kat, and robbie, and we're at least voting with reasoning, it's not just opportunistic.
|
|
The Missing Link
Yellow Belt
[M:1000]
"I just saved you from Ganon!"[ss:District Court No. 76]
Posts: 223
|
Post by The Missing Link on May 9, 2012 0:14:30 GMT -6
... really... >_< This is all the conversation that's happened so far today? This is disappointing. Erniewan, thanks for answering those curiosities. I'm not all up in my news about all the relationships and friendships between folk here since this ain't my native stomping ground, but that does make a lot of sense. Hm...I've got a good feeling about Ernie. I want to have a good feeling about TML but he's just so hard to read and also Nintendo you made me sad >:[ Wait, what? What'd I do to make you sad? I will concur with you that Ernie's at least being forthcoming and is making the effort to be helpful. After some thought, I think I'd have to put him as my 2nd most likely Townie at this point. Kira I don't have the same view on though; this may be like his M.O., but I don't have much of an M.O. to compare against... and the answer still rubs me the wrong way.
|
|
|
Post by capcommaster on May 9, 2012 5:23:57 GMT -6
Well I did some extensive reading and I think I know who I am going to vote for but its strictly cause right now this just seems like a waste of time. But first my question and then I want to ask some of my own. "Ready to get off the fence and take a side on one of the many suspects?" I believe so but I need to be sure right now with who I am voting for. Unfortunately since Soft was janitored and no info on her alignment cant really make a good idea who may have been involved in it. Im going to ask my questions now. Kat - You seemed to be pretty sure NPR was mafia by his odd reactions on Day 1 and you still seem to think it with how hes playing now. Yet you havent placed a vote on him yet today. Now I am not completely sure on this and which side is telling the truth but to me this whole thing is crazy to get dragged to a vote. If he hadnt acted the way he did yesterday would you voted for him today for the namecalling and whiteknighting? NPR - Now I dont got much to say but I wasnt honestly convinced by joking about this whole bit and just not voting when she suddenly got defensive about your joke post. Though I will mention one odd bit when you suddenly did thought she was trolling and voted for Jkilla. I guess my question is if your not suspicious of Kat then who are you suspicious of? Erniewan - Hmm well I got not much to say in the lines of getting info for whats going on. Well...what do you think about asking questions to find clearer reads? Do you find it more effective at solidifying suspicions? MiracleFassad, Kirawillwin, and Robbiecon - This question is for the 3 of you since you guys havent been actively posting too much (Which isnt good >:[ ). Who are you currently suspicious of and why? DogInjuries - Now I dont really like playing with "Meta" reasonings but it is nice to get to know someone and how they play as town or mafia. But do you think regular play style and personality is important for analysis to see who is scum and who is town? werdna and Jkilla - Since you 2 are new I guess the only question I have is: How are you with getting into the style of forum mafia on DEM? Im not sure if you 2 actually has played forum mafia but if you have I hope you can enjoy it here . TML - Well I was going to ask the same question I asked Ernie to you but then decided I already spread some questions between people. But anyway what do you think about Kat saying that your hard to read? I wasnt in Nintendo mafia but i do remember seeing you were the final mafiat in the game and thats pretty dangerous. Right now Im not sure what to read you as but hopefully it wont be as hard as Kat puts it. Hopefully you guys can answer that all before the day ends. I may need to read more on whats going on between Kat and NPR since everyone seems to be focused on that >.<
|
|
Coyote
Orange Belt
[M:3050]
[A1i:3][ss:Standard]
Posts: 370
|
Post by Coyote on May 9, 2012 8:15:08 GMT -6
Sure, why not? Anytime you can spot trends from game to game, that's potentially helpful. Unfortunately I lack that luxury since I haven't played here in a few years. But on the flip side, it doesn't help me much for Kat to suggest Ernie appears town because she knows him better, as they could be in cahoots.
I'm not particularly suspicious of anyone right now, but I do get a town vibe from TML.
|
|
|
Post by NPR on May 9, 2012 11:25:35 GMT -6
In what universe was what happened to me D1 a bandwagon? I'm sort of suspicious of both Jkilla and werdna right now. They had this vendetta with each other yesterday, and today, it's stopped stone cold. Maybe they thought that they could start that, and in case one of them dies, then the other would be presumed town
(Totally unrelated, but psst, DEM people need to confirm their role in the VGF Puzzlemaster mafia)
|
|
Coyote
Orange Belt
[M:3050]
[A1i:3][ss:Standard]
Posts: 370
|
Post by Coyote on May 9, 2012 13:48:04 GMT -6
TML, can you speculate why softguitar was targeted last night? She interacted with you a bit more than the others before her death, as I recall. Not accusing you, but do you have any hunches there?
JKilla, are you going to vote for werdna today? Or is that dispute settled?
|
|
|
Post by Nyan Kat on May 9, 2012 16:23:46 GMT -6
TML- you flipped .5 and that made me sad! Kinda intimidated me a little capcom- Probably not. I've left my vote off because I really don't think he's going to be lynched any time soon and would like to look elsewhere. Of course, now I don't know where to look =/
|
|
|
Post by Erniewan on May 9, 2012 17:29:35 GMT -6
Erniewan - Hmm well I got not much to say in the lines of getting info for whats going on. Well...what do you think about asking questions to find clearer reads? Do you find it more effective at solidifying suspicions? It's a good way to hit multiple targets/topics at once, that's for sure. Like I said, it feels like some players are answering only they're questions and saying nothing else. At least there are more people (like you) asking more questions so they can't just lurk, or at least I hope they won't. I encourage everyone to ask their own questions. Sure, why not? Anytime you can spot trends from game to game, that's potentially helpful. Unfortunately I lack that luxury since I haven't played here in a few years. But on the flip side, it doesn't help me much for Kat to suggest Ernie appears town because she knows him better, as they could be in cahoots. I'm not particularly suspicious of anyone right now, but I do get a town vibe from TML. Cahoots or not, it's risky for mafia to back each other so blatantly. That's why it's good to not only ask people who they suspect, but who they trust. TML's right about a lot of people not posting though... Day's not lasting too much longer, we need some discussion!
|
|
|
Post by werdna0418 on May 9, 2012 19:28:44 GMT -6
werdna and Jkilla - Since you 2 are new I guess the only question I have is: How are you with getting into the style of forum mafia on DEM? Im not sure if you 2 actually has played forum mafia but if you have I hope you can enjoy it here . first time playing here i sometimes forget to check the forum other than that i like
|
|
The Missing Link
Yellow Belt
[M:1000]
"I just saved you from Ganon!"[ss:District Court No. 76]
Posts: 223
|
Post by The Missing Link on May 9, 2012 23:16:12 GMT -6
TML - Well I was going to ask the same question I asked Ernie to you but then decided I already spread some questions between people. But anyway what do you think about Kat saying that your hard to read? I wasnt in Nintendo mafia but i do remember seeing you were the final mafiat in the game and thats pretty dangerous. Right now Im not sure what to read you as but hopefully it wont be as hard as Kat puts it. I was the "final mafiat" in that game insofar that I wasn't a mafiat the entire game; I was a last-minute admission into that circle... and I only gained admission into it by getting the Mafia to target me directly for a kill. Which meant I had to annoy them quite a bit. Hence... I had to be a thorn in their side, which would make me look uncharacteristically Townie. Or at least this was more or less my strategy during that game. Specifically, I got indoctrinated into my Mafia group the same night as my "recruiter" got me. I think, generally speaking, that's one primary reason why I'm a difficult read as it comes to Kat; I had to play a Townie game... and timing made it convenient for me to switch sides at the last minute. Kat had me pegged as Townie for most the game... but my final alignment was contrary to it. So as for how Kat feels about me? I'm really not that surprised given the circumstances. Our history in Mafia spans two games... and her second game she was remarkably busy for the duration of it. TML- you flipped .5 and that made me sad! Kinda intimidated me a little Oh... for a second I had this disturbing feeling that I'd inadvertently done something personal to you in the game. That makes me feel a little better. TML, can you speculate why softguitar was targeted last night? She interacted with you a bit more than the others before her death, as I recall. Not accusing you, but do you have any hunches there? Hmmm. Honestly... there's not a lot to really speculate off of. I really do feel like making any sort of real educated guesses might just send me down the wrong path in one way or another. If I had to guess anything, it's because maybe she was active? When I'm Mafia, I know my first instinct isn't to kill of the inactives. But beyond that, I really can't know. If we knew her role, that might glean some iota of insight. You know, given the circumstances... I think I'm going to be disruptive. I think some discussion needs provoking. As of this point, everyone has 24 hours with which to cast a vote for someone. If you don't, well, it's not going to be pretty.And so no one thinks I'm not playing by the same rules... Vote: JKillaI've got three reasons for this vote. The first of which is that I really haven't been a fan of JKilla since yesterday. The second of which is what NPR mentioned, the sudden truce is... very weird. JKilla, what gives? Why haven't you continued your deal with Werdna from yesterday?
|
|
|
Post by NPR on May 9, 2012 23:35:42 GMT -6
I'm super close to voting Jkilla, but I want to hear him answer explain his cause for the truce. Gunning for someone one day, and not even noticing them the next day is very wishy-washy.
|
|
Coyote
Orange Belt
[M:3050]
[A1i:3][ss:Standard]
Posts: 370
|
Post by Coyote on May 10, 2012 6:54:51 GMT -6
vote: JKilla
I was planning to wait too, but if he defends himself adequately, then I'll reconsider. I think both JKilla and werdna have been acting strangely, and one or both is scum. So let's light a fire beneath them and solve this. We're already one in the hole, so another no-lynch day is going to hurt.
Werdna, why sign up if you're going to be "forgetting" to check the boards? Why not help us find scum?
|
|
|
Post by Erniewan on May 10, 2012 7:15:17 GMT -6
What truce? Lack of attack doesn't really imply a truce... but they could use some pressure to get posting.
I'm still suspicious of NPR, btw.
|
|
JKilla
White Belt
[M:500]
[A1i:5][ss:Starmen]
Posts: 48
|
Post by JKilla on May 10, 2012 10:38:47 GMT -6
So I go away for a few days and i'm just getting bandwagoned. Nice
And yes, i'm going to stick with my vote
vote: Werdna0418
|
|
|
Post by Nyan Kat on May 10, 2012 10:41:59 GMT -6
I'm still willing to vote off jkilla, although not as much as I was before- if you need me to complete that lynch then so be it.
I, too, am still suspicious of NPR, but I wanna give him more time to SD if he's scum.
For now, though... I'm not getting the towniest of vibes from XX Stone for his soft defense of NPR. I mean, yeah, he gets lynched early a lot, but still. Doesn't even offer any other suspects to the table. I know that this is only one reason in a sea of reasons for voting other people, but it's still worth looking at. vote: XX Stone[/color]
|
|
JKilla
White Belt
[M:500]
[A1i:5][ss:Starmen]
Posts: 48
|
Post by JKilla on May 10, 2012 10:42:42 GMT -6
@capcom
It's more fun playing games on fourms like this and you get to see everything more layed out.
@dog Injuries
Well, i'm obviously not scum with werdna since i'm voting against him, plus we've both been targeting each other. So it's impossible that we're working together.
|
|
|
Post by Nyan Kat on May 10, 2012 10:43:31 GMT -6
Erm....no. It's totally possible you're bussing each other. In fact now I think it's probable.
|
|
JKilla
White Belt
[M:500]
[A1i:5][ss:Starmen]
Posts: 48
|
Post by JKilla on May 10, 2012 10:48:07 GMT -6
@npr, this feud hasn't been at a truce. I have been busy with real life and this is the only time i had to come on here and thanks for the extension monstrman. is it still take 7 to lynch?
|
|
|
Post by Nyan Kat on May 10, 2012 10:51:01 GMT -6
Yeah, 7 to lynch
|
|
|
Post by NPR on May 10, 2012 10:52:04 GMT -6
So I go away for a few days and i'm just getting bandwagoned. Nice And yes, i'm going to stick with my vote vote: Werdna0418You posted 4 times before this post in D2. Why did you place your vote back on him as soon as a couple people mention it. instead of first thing in the day?
|
|
|
Post by NPR on May 10, 2012 10:52:39 GMT -6
oh hi there ninjas!
|
|
|
Post by Nyan Kat on May 10, 2012 10:53:10 GMT -6
good god tell me about it I was supposed to get dressed to go out shopping with my mom fifteen minutes ago
|
|
Coyote
Orange Belt
[M:3050]
[A1i:3][ss:Standard]
Posts: 370
|
Post by Coyote on May 10, 2012 11:05:01 GMT -6
JKilla, that's a pretty poor defense actually. Not exactly unheard of for scum to vote each other to throw the town off their trail. Got anything else?
|
|
|
Post by NPR on May 10, 2012 11:25:21 GMT -6
@capcom It's more fun playing games on fourms like this and you get to see everything more layed out. @dog Injuries Well, i'm obviously not scum with werdna since i'm voting against him, plus we've both been targeting each other. So it's impossible that we're working together. As I said before, you both could be mafia, and could both be doing this so that if one of you dies, the other would be presumed town.
|
|
|
Post by Erniewan on May 10, 2012 12:07:34 GMT -6
I could see one of them being mafia, but I don't see any reason to suspect that they are both in it together. They're new to forum mafia, I think this seems a bit too opportunistic.
I agree with Kat about XX Stone though.
|
|
Coyote
Orange Belt
[M:3050]
[A1i:3][ss:Standard]
Posts: 370
|
Post by Coyote on May 10, 2012 12:42:24 GMT -6
My hunch says one of them is scum, but likely not both. Could be, but my main point is that JKilla's defense was weak. I'm going to stand by my vote unless he can tell me why voting for werdna is a better bet.
Ernie, if you had to vote this moment, who would it be?
|
|
|
Post by XX Stone on May 10, 2012 13:21:56 GMT -6
For now, though... I'm not getting the towniest of vibes from XX Stone for his soft defense of NPR. I mean, yeah, he gets lynched early a lot, but still. Doesn't even offer any other suspects to the table. vote: XX Stone[/color][/quote] I'll admit I've been barely hanging around, and trying to prevent any lynches for stupid reasons. I blame college. I'm sure you've noticed my lack of enthusiasm lately. I have literally no suspicions. In a game this small though, we have to make sure not to mislynch. Voting for NPR "because his playstyle is scummy" is not a good reason for a lynch.
|
|
|
Post by Nyan Kat on May 10, 2012 14:58:49 GMT -6
I don't think it's both of [jkilla, werdna]. I also feel like- jkilla's new to forum mafia, yes, but he's played on facebook before, so idk.
jkilla, how long have you been playing?
|
|
JKilla
White Belt
[M:500]
[A1i:5][ss:Starmen]
Posts: 48
|
Post by JKilla on May 11, 2012 0:54:10 GMT -6
@ Kat
For Facebook Mafia, 3 years.. but the gameplay was different compared to this. It's also been like 3 years since I last played an actual game of mafia like this.
@npr
The reason on why I waited was because I wanted to see if any of the PR's got some intel. since this is the 2nd day now.
@dog
You sated that my defense is weak, I'm trying to make a case for myself. Unlike Werdna, whose only posted once than went invisible since that post. Plus, I want to contribute to this game. Even if I have to fight every round, but that is up to the town of Dr.Who!
|
|
|
Post by Nyan Kat on May 11, 2012 1:25:15 GMT -6
Different enough for you to not bus a partner?
PR fishing oh noes
I'm going to go ahead and change my vote before I forget/get too busy at work/etc unvote vote: jkilla p.sure werdna just keeps forgetting about the game tbh...
|
|